Sorry, No 2003 S&W Winter Match

Rob Boudrie
December 19, 2002

I regret to inform the membership that the hoped for match at the S&W range in early 2003 will not occur because of changes in the match fee required by Smith & Wesson for use of that facility. My original match proposal is available here .

In my proposal to S&W, I proposed a match fee of $9.00 per competitor, and adding use of 3 lanes on the indoor commercial range for a standards exercise to boost the stage count. I suggested this amount, since it reflected a reasonable increase in the rate over last season (a 28% increase, or a 7% increase in the per-range amount). The total paid to S&W would have been further increased if we succeeded in filling two days worth of squads. In addition to the $7.00 per shooter fee, last season's match director (Mark Agerholm) also agreed to a minimum of $150.00 per match.

Terms offered for 2003 by the same S&W manager responsible for last season's matches were substantially different:

I have therefore abandoned my efforts at organizing this match, since I do not feel we can "make it work" with these numbers. In addition to the more than doubling of the fee, the $2000.00 minimum presents a significant obstacle since we will have no way of knowing, in advance, how many people would sign up with a $45 match fee, and there is no funding to back such a guarantee should turnout be insufficient.

To answer the obvious question, no, I did not respond to S&W with a counter offer. The terms offered were very far from what I could have made work with a $45 match fee, including the usual expenses and out of town range officers. I offered S&W what we could afford, and they responded with a number which was, for all practical purposes, "out of the ballpark", and set a minimum fee which presented an insurmountable obstacle to the contemplated match.

My Reply to S&W

I have posted my response to the civilian training coordinator at S&W below. I have omitted his name and email address, since it is not my desire to have members contacting him to complain about this decision. Although I would have preferred that S&W continue their past practice of affordable range fees in support of our shooting sport, we must respect the fact that this person has every right to set fees as he feels appropriate for his business unit within Smith & Wesson.

I am not posting the email from S&W explaining their proposal, since I consider it impolite to post non-public emails without explicit permission from the sender.

If anyone wishes to contact S&W to attempt to rent to their ranges and organize a match, please let me know and I will provide you with the necessary contact information.

My Email to S&W

I sent the following email on the evening of December 12, 2002. Dear <name omitted>,

Thank you for getting back to me so quickly.

Unfortunately, the match I was trying to arrange wouldn't be able to support the range rental rates your facility requires.

The $15 per person would be very tight with the budget I was trying to put together. The goal was to run the match with a reasonably low entry fee, and use the proceeds to help clubs pay for staff expenses such as hotel bills. (The detailed proposal to the USPSA members in the area is at www.boudrie.com/sw.html)

Also, as an event being run by Area 7 (and not by "USPSA National"), there would be no source of funds to underwrite the $2000 financial guarantee you require should turnout not be sufficient to generate that amount. Assuming 7 ranges, two Saturday squads of 6 shooters each and one Sunday squad of 8 shooters would be 140 shooters - barely above the 133 required to "make minimum" ... and that's if we fill up the match.

Last season S&W charged the matches $7/shooter, $150 minimum, for the same 1/2 day per shooter on the range as this match would have used. The service was $5/shooter the year before. While price changes are to be expected with any product or service, I was more than a little surprised to see the per-head fee more than double, and the minimum increase by a factor of more than thirteen.

Although an Area 7 USPSA/IPSC match won't work at the range for the winter of 2003, I do wish you the best of luck in your range rental business. I will not hesitate to contact you if a future indoor USPSA match would be able to support the fees at the level your range now requires.

Best Wishes,

Rob Boudrie
USPSA Area 7 Director
rob@boudrie.com
< phone number omitted> home
< phone number omitted> days

About Smith & Wesson

Smith & Wesson has a long history of generous contribution to USPSA, which continues to this day in the form of their presence on the USPSA Nationals Sponsors roster as a Factory Gun Stage Sponsor. In addition, there are numerous examples of S&W demonstrating support for USPSA through contributions to various large matches. I have personally experienced an enthusiastic "yes" on numerous occasions from S&W when I was a major match prize coordinator seeking donation of prize table firearms. The Smith and Wesson Corporation is a USPSA Sponsor and supporter.

I do not consider the response of the Smith and Wesson range regarding rental rates to be any indication of a lack of support for USPSA / IPSC, but rather a business decision made by one specific department within that firm.

Thank you to those of you who volunteered

I would like to thank the various clubs and individuals throughout the area who offered to help make this match happen by running a stage. Northeast Section Coordinator Ray Goguen offered to serve as match treasurer; Gary Thompson and the Pathfinder crew were already at the point of discussing specifics of their stage designs; Jon Whitmore of Square Deal Sportsmen indicated probable interest, and Jayne and Gary Spooner and their team from Vermont were eager to come down to "make it happen." In addition, numerous individuals from various clubs in the Northeast Section expressed interest in volunteering their efforts towards this project.

The "next step" after obtaining a range committment would have been to contact all clubs within Area 7 to announce the match, and arrange for a club or group of individuals to "adopt" each of the match stages.

Rob Boudrie